Gloucester v London Irish - ECC Final - (21st May 2006)

Once upon a time the Sunbury Centre producd match previews and reports so you'll find all our old ones here ...

Gloucester v London Irish - ECC Final - (21st May 2006)

by AlecW on Tue May 16, 2006 5:40 pm

ECC v Gloucester: Preview – It's Been a Long Hard Season

On Sunday, London Irish meet Gloucester in the final of the ECC at the totally ridiculous, Sky-blackmailed time of 12:15. The first train into London from Gloucester – except I think it may be a bus, due to Engineering works! – gets in after kick off … Or to go from Gloucester to Twickenham involves going via Newport to Reading to … missing the match, messieurs-dames.

But since when has ERC bothered a tu’penny damn about the supporter – grass roots or not? As long as the ground is sold out for the cameras and the “Equipe Sandwiches-Crevettes” get their plum seats. So – get Sky to squeeze it in between Darlington Corinthians v Halifax Town Renegades in the Premierchampionship Division 24 (North) Play-off quarter-finals and All-in Crown Green Darts, pick a stadium so small you KNOW you’re going to fill it and put the champagne on ice, Monsieur Jean-Pierre Lux. Great player. Crap administrator. As Jim Naughtie said on the Today Programme yesterday (talking about a certain water company): “I wouldn’t ask them to organise a celebration in a brewery” – nor yet a rugby match at a rugby ground, Jim.

Still, the supporters of Gloucester and Irish have long traditions of festivities together and I have no doubt we will cope. Brunch, anyone?

We have said again and again that Irish have done amazingly well to get this far and that we’d have settled for this, that or the other at the start of the season. It’s funny, but on reflection I think that this is a tad patronising – I include myself in this criticism. It slightly undervalues the efforts of the whole playing and coaching staff – ‘never mind, boys, we never really expected you to achieve what you have’. In the words of young Mr Grace “You’ve all Done Very Well”.

Well, you could argue that, so far, we’ve done no more than achieve the targets Brian Smith set at the start of the season. Heineken Cup qualification and a place in the top four of the GP. It has been inspiring and uplifting to move from scoring the fewest tries in the Premiership last season to the most tries this season. We have played some stunning rugby too, with Hodgson, Flutey, Catt, Tiesi/Feau’nati, Tagicakibau, Ojo and Armitage rivalling some of the performances of the Putt, Bachop, Venter, Burrows, Woods, Bishop & O’Shea backline. It may have been beyond the supporters’ expectations, but I’d argue that it sure as hell hasn’t been beyond those of Brian, Toby et al! There’s a streak of the perfectionist in Brian, tempered with a good dose of pragmatism, as I said in the Leicester preview.

And there’s unfinished business. You may remember the third part of Brian’s rugby “Tripos” (sorry, Brian – I know you went to the “other” place!) this season. To win something. And we have the opportunity next Sunday.

Well, we got absolutely blattered by Leicester last week. Let’s face it, they were very, very impressive and did not allow us to play. Our famed offloads didn’t happen – too many Tigers in our faces. Leicester were arguably all over the ball at the breakdown. We were outmuscled and out-hassled. The impression I got watching the TV and reading Brian’s comments since, is that the LI side was slightly cobbled together using string and sticky tape. So we aren’t going to be winning the Premiership this year – was that ever more than a dream?

And here is my worry about Sunday. Was the Tigers game a “step too far” for our team and especially the forwards? I am no expert, but I observed the following on Sunday…

Front row under pressure. Not having Rautenbach, Coetzee and Collins available is hurting us, big time. Neal and our “demented Rhinoceros” need to be wrapped in cotton wool. I hope to God that Neal’s knee is OK. I’ve given up hope that we’ll see Faan again this season. No offence to Tom Warren, or to Paicey’s propping ability, but a Cup Final is NOT the time to go down that route…! Second row were not competing on opposition lineouts – strange. Our back row (sorry to say it) were played off the park by a superb Leicester unit. No offence to Declan, Olivier and Juan, but they were well and truly beasted by Jennings, Corry and Moody.

And then we look at the backs. Here I have one massive and overriding worry. Place-kicking. Riki showed in his first game for his new club exactly how good he can be. Recently, while allegedly carrying a foot injury, he has been pants. Maybe not his fault, but it’s a fact. Luckily, his play with the ball in hand has been so inspirational (combined with Catt’s sublime distribution) that we have not needed goal kicking to get us through tight games. We’ve scored tries, tries, tries. Five (or seven) points are better than three!

So is there a dilemma for Brian here? Does he play Flutey or Barry Everitt? Barry will kick the goals, but arguably he will not ignite our outside backs in the way Riki can.

So I can see a very similar side taking the field this Sunday to the one last Sunday. Barring one of our injured doing a Lazarus, the forwards will be the same, with the possibility of Kennedy and Murphy starting. The backs will probably be the same too, with maybe Everitt and / or Tiesi starting for Flutey and / or Feau’nati. But there are four factors that might make that prediction a load of ill-informed hot air!

a) Any injuries we don’t yet know about
b) Any Lazaruses “they” have been keeping quiet about
c) The Brian Smith Master Plan
d) My ignorance.

I sincerely hope that a) is not a factor, that b) is and that c) is a corker. The Master Plan for Wasps wasn’t bad, after all! I also hope that Smith has been keeping something back for this game, but I fear that the superglue, string, sellotape elastoplast and pain killers will have to come out… It would be great to see otherwise, when the team is announced. I can’t do a lot about d) – sorry…!

Gloucester, on the other hand, have had a fortnight’s rest after their tumultuous final “regular season” game against Wasps. They’ll have had their bruises soothed, their minds rested and will be raring to go. Strangely for a Gloucester side, their backs look to be a larger threat than the forwards, with Lamb, Allen and Simpson-Daniel likely to be very dangerous. The forwards will be no pushovers – no Gloucester pack ever is. Names like Boer, Collazo, Forrester, Cornwell, Brown, Hazell, Azam – nah, they’re not exactly weak! The back row, especially, look very impressive and it could be a hard afternoon in the battle for ball on the floor. Irish haven’t a chance really.

Or do we?

The argument that Gloucester will be well rested cuts both ways. It has happened in the past that a team that has had a rest for a couple of weeks has gone off the boil. Indeed it happened to Gloucester a couple of years ago, where they “won” the Premiership by a country mile, yet crashed spectacularly to Wasps come Twickenham time. Dean Ryan will obviously be aware of this factor – and will have acted accordingly.

And I suppose that Ryan has a similar dilemma to Brian Smith. The conservative option of Ludovic Mercier, who is one of very few rivals in the GP to Andy Goode for length and accuracy of kick, or the mercurial talents of young Ryan Lamb to get the backs moving? Well, we saw what happened in the game against Wasps… A Lamb-led Gloucester backline showed no fear and built a healthy lead. Ryan arguably decided to shut up shop and put Mercier on to close out the game. Result? Misery, with Worsley’s try sealing the game late on.

Dean Ryan was always a hard-nosed, uncompromising barsteward as a player. I doubt he’s changed or mellowed much. I think he’ll give youth a chance, with the option of Mercier off the bench.

This one is far too close to call. Irish are in bits, but will stick to their principles of quick ball and fast, counterattacking backs. It has, after all, got them this far. And Irish also have the (unique?) distinction of having beaten all the West Country clubs, both Home and Away this season. Gloucester will mix forward power and backline speed. It could, genuinely, be a cracking game. As so often, the contest for the ball at the breakdown will be crucial.

I will be sitting in the East Stand as nervous as hell. I don’t “do” these big games very well and will be fidgeting madly. Sorry in advance to my neighbours! At the Powergen Cup final on 20th April 2002, many of the London Irish support admitted to “expecting to lose, but hoping to win”. I would argue that we can be far more optimistic about this one.

Last game of the season – all or nothing. Bodies on the line. Give it everything. Afterwards, I suspect that a number of supporters and players will congregate at Sunbury for a few jars, to reflect on the season and to compare “holiday” plans. Catt is going to Australia and Horak, Armitage, Hodgson, Roche, Kennedy and Paice to Canada. No doubt many supporters will want to thank the players for their efforts and to say one or two final good-byes. It’ll be a nice afternoon, win or lose. And no doubt AG will be consumed!

Just pray that Hinge & Bracket don’t tip us to win!
AlecW
User avatar
AlecW
 
Posts: 1173
Joined: Tue Nov 01, 2005 10:44 am
Location: Central London

by dom_pedro on Tue May 16, 2006 9:37 pm

Really enjoyed reading that ... thanks.
This cruel country has driven me down, teased me and lied.
I've only sad stories to tell to this town
My dreams have withered and died.
User avatar
dom_pedro
Site Admin
 
Posts: 2719
Joined: Wed Oct 12, 2005 1:20 pm
Location: Dead in the Sea

by Mrs Chicken on Tue May 16, 2006 10:45 pm

Our back row (sorry to say it) were played off the park by a superb Leicester unit. No offence to Declan, Olivier and Juan, but they were well and truly beasted by Jennings, Corry and Moody.

Yeah, but no, but yeah, but... true, very true. But look at the names in that back row again. Declan (looking good at the moment, especially with the Samson locks), Olivier (Magners is a quality brew) and Juan (nothing corny about that beef there).

Put it this way (this is a tangent, ok, but bear with me) - there's nothing wrong with Wasps. They're one of the most formidable sides in the premiership and look what Irish did to them a couple of weeks ago. Sometimes, you put two good teams together and the one with the edge (Wasps in this case) come up against a team who just have everything going their way. Skill + The Hand of Lugh = we're going to beat you no matter what Dallaglio says to the ref.

I think that may be partly what happened to Irish against Leicester, only this time Irish were Wasps. In other words, there's nothing wrong with Irish. And there's nothing wrong with Wasps. But both teams got blown away. Shite happens. Win some, lose some.

Basically, having supported Irish for about 10 years now, I've got enough grey hairs to realise that it takes more than a bit of the luck of the Irish to get them to 3rd place in a very competitive league. It might get them to the middle of the table, or out of a relegation battle by the skin of their teeth, but I feel that they're now reaching the point where the opposition start thinking "yikes, we're playing Irish today" which, in my experience over the years, is how I've felt when Irish have played Leicester, and Tigers, and the hideous Bath. It will take another two seasons, I feel, to cement that impression, but there's a chance at the moment that it might happen.

So, in a very long winded and roundabout way, I'm saying look again at that backrow, the one that was outperformed by the Tigers backrow on Sunday. Well, they're the same guys who have done pretty well over the past season. Nothing wrong with them. Nothing wrong with the rest of the team either. Nice legs, shame about the front row, but you have to learn to carry injury and still come out on top. Leicester do it. Wasps do it. Sale do it. Irish have to be able to do it too.

In other words - game too far? Nah! No reason why Irish shouldn't take it. And even if they lose, I don't think it signals some kind of false dawn. Look at Sale - how long have they been there or thereabouts? But they're yet to put something meaningful in the cabinet. There was a time under the watchful eye of Dick Best when Irish became the team no one wanted to play. And yet I remember that horrible fortnight when Irish were thrown out of the Tetley Bitter Cup by Wasps (the unofficial Webmaster Dom Benson almost wailed in despair when he realised Wasps had pulled the on form team in the draw) and kicked to high heaven by Wasps, again, in the league. At that point it really did look like a false dawn, and so it proved to be.

Whether it's the same this time or not is yet to be proved, but Irish are in good company. Are they're in top company or not? That depends on next season, and the one after. Agree 100% with Alec - our ambition should be greater than that 2002 Powergen Final where it was "yeah well, what the heck", and the win was a wonderful surprise. Never mind surprises. Irish should be on the way to making the win an inevitability, or at least thinking that way. And that goes for the supporters too!

Forget Leicester and forget the miserable, unsmiling backrow dullards in their silly stripey shirts. They can shove right off, quite frankly. That was then, this is now.

GET IN THERE!
User avatar
Mrs Chicken
 
Posts: 767
Joined: Wed Oct 12, 2005 8:33 pm
Location: The Coop, Venta Belgarum

by AlecW on Wed May 17, 2006 6:51 am

Inspiring words from the red-head on the quayside...

Now - where's that Armada?

:P
AlecW
User avatar
AlecW
 
Posts: 1173
Joined: Tue Nov 01, 2005 10:44 am
Location: Central London

by GWaGG on Wed May 17, 2006 10:04 am

Excellent reading Alec!
User avatar
GWaGG
 
Posts: 57
Joined: Tue Nov 08, 2005 2:37 pm
Location: Oxford

by Mrs Chicken on Wed May 17, 2006 10:04 am

That's almost as bad as being compared to Mrs Thatcher.
User avatar
Mrs Chicken
 
Posts: 767
Joined: Wed Oct 12, 2005 8:33 pm
Location: The Coop, Venta Belgarum

by AlecW on Wed May 17, 2006 10:31 am

Well, you said it! Both were redheads of course.

Did I say I meant 1588, or 1982?
AlecW
User avatar
AlecW
 
Posts: 1173
Joined: Tue Nov 01, 2005 10:44 am
Location: Central London

by Mrs Chicken on Wed May 17, 2006 10:37 am

Mrs T a redhead? Are you colour blind?

Here, let me punch you in the head. It might help adjust your eyes.
User avatar
Mrs Chicken
 
Posts: 767
Joined: Wed Oct 12, 2005 8:33 pm
Location: The Coop, Venta Belgarum

by AlecW on Wed May 17, 2006 12:02 pm

Nasty tempers these redheads can have...

:shock:
AlecW
User avatar
AlecW
 
Posts: 1173
Joined: Tue Nov 01, 2005 10:44 am
Location: Central London

by PaulHP on Wed May 17, 2006 6:33 pm

She's got her red wine head on! Aaaaarrrggghhh
User avatar
PaulHP
Site Admin
 
Posts: 1357
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2005 11:38 am
Location: Snowy Essex on me sofa

by Mrs Chicken on Wed May 17, 2006 7:21 pm

I no longer drink red wine.

So there!
User avatar
Mrs Chicken
 
Posts: 767
Joined: Wed Oct 12, 2005 8:33 pm
Location: The Coop, Venta Belgarum

by Shawshank on Wed May 17, 2006 8:35 pm

Not sure about Mother Hen's comments re Wasps. I think our win was the tipping point on the irreversible decline of a once great team.

Look at their front row now - very pedestrian. Shaw is now well past his best, Doolally is becoming a sad pastiche of his former self, and can you honestly compare an axis of Reddan/Staunton with Howley/King...? Abbott is joining Quins, and Lewsey is a pale shadow of his former self. Voyce is about their only consistently good player at present.

Glos will be well rested for Sunday, will it be a game too far for our lads? So long as we put up a good fight and give it a lash, I'll be happy.
User avatar
Shawshank
 
Posts: 780
Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2005 11:43 am
Location: In the East Stand

by Mrs Chicken on Wed May 17, 2006 9:11 pm

Well, they certainly seem to miss Chuckles Gatland.
User avatar
Mrs Chicken
 
Posts: 767
Joined: Wed Oct 12, 2005 8:33 pm
Location: The Coop, Venta Belgarum


Return to Old Previews and Reports

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests